From September through October 2026, our research team evaluated insurance agencies that write coverage for commercial trucks across the United States, with an emphasis on agencies headquartered or highly active in the Midwest. We focused on agencies and brokerages that place coverage for trucking businesses and support them between renewals with safety programs, certificate service, and claims guidance. Each agency was scored using an eight-factor algorithm:
- Structured Risk Management Programming (20%): Agencies with named, repeatable loss control programs help carriers lower accident frequency and bring a stronger safety story to underwriters at renewal.
- Certificate Accuracy and Broker Verification Readiness (17%): Brokers and shippers now verify coverage before releasing freight, so agencies that issue accurate certificates quickly and meet published verification standards keep trucks loaded.
- Trucking Association Engagement (15%): Agencies active in national and state trucking associations stay closer to regulatory changes, safety initiatives, and the issues driving carrier costs.
- Family Ownership and Local Decision-Making (15%): Independent, family, or employee ownership keeps service decisions with people who know the client rather than with a consolidator’s corporate office.
- Average Review Score (10%): Client ratings from the BBB, Birdeye, Trustpilot, and similar platforms, averaged where an agency appears on more than one, show how consistently an agency delivers on its promises.
- Year Founded (9%): Longevity signals deep carrier relationships, claims experience, and staying power through multiple hard insurance markets.
- Price Range (8%): Rated from $ (least flexible) to $$$$$ (most flexible), this reflects how well an agency can fit coverage to different budgets through carrier access and the range of operations it prices for.
- Awards and Recognition (6%): Industry, carrier, and workplace honors offer third-party validation of an agency’s standing.
The Best Insurance Agencies for Commercial Trucks
| Rank | Agency | Risk Management Programming | Certificate & Broker Verification | Trucking Association Engagement | Ownership | Year Founded | Avg. Review Score | Price Range | Awards & Recognition |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Truck Writers | Trademarked Mile Markers risk management program; CSA, safety document, policy template, and video libraries | Highway Certified Insurance Agency founding member; online certificate requests; 24/7 self-service per trip excess coverage | Supports ATA, Minnesota, Iowa, South Dakota, and Wisconsin trucking associations and Women In Trucking | Independent; family-owned across three generations | 1983 | 5.0/5.0 | $$$$$ | Highway Certified Insurance Agency founding member (2026); profiled by Acuity Insurance for three generations of family-focused success |
| 2 | TrueNorth Companies | Transportation risk consulting; fleet risk data through its partnership with Haul | Highway Certified Insurance Agency founding member | Works with state trucking associations and industry nonprofits | Closely held, privately owned | 2001 | 3.9/5.0 | $$$ | ATA Mike Russell Trucking Image Award (2022); USA Today Top Workplace (2026); Highway Certified founding member |
| 3 | Cottingham & Butler | In-house Safety Management Services Company; transportation safety assessments, CSA and DataQ support, mock compliance investigations | Certificates handled through transportation account teams | Hosts an annual Transportation Summit for trucking owners and executives | Privately held | 1887 | Not publicly aggregated | $$$ | Sole producer for the two largest transportation captives in the world |
| 4 | OOIDA Truck Insurance | Compliance and business support tools for association members | Highway Certified Insurance Agency founding member | Operated by the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, the national voice of owner-operators | Association-owned; insurance revenue reinvested in advocacy | 1973 | Not publicly aggregated | $$$$ | Highway Certified Insurance Agency founding member (2026) |
| 5 | Holmes Murphy | Customized safety and compliance audits; benchmarking data tools | Certificates handled through a dedicated transportation team | Transportation practice rooted in early trucking clients | Employee-owned, independent | 1932 | Not publicly aggregated | $$$ | Business Insurance No. 1 Best Place to Work in Insurance; founder inducted into the Insurance Hall of Fame |
| 6 | Joe Morten & Son | Top G.E.A.R. program; loss control services | Certificates handled through regional service locations | Roots in helping truckers obtain operating authority | Privately held | 1936 | Not publicly aggregated | $$$$ | Largest agency of Great West Casualty Company |
| 7 | Marvin Johnson & Associates | Safety services and accident packets for fleets | Bond and permit services alongside certificates | Promotes clients’ interests through affiliated trucking associations | Family-owned, third generation | 1971 | Not publicly aggregated (BBB A+) | $$$$ | Profiled by Acuity Insurance at its 50th anniversary; largest independent truck insurance agency in Indiana, Ohio, and Illinois |
| 8 | Kapnick Insurance | Risk management advisory through its transportation and towing practice | Certificates handled through client executives | Active in the towing community | Family-owned since 1946 | 1946 | 3.0/5.0 | $$$ | Insurance Journal Best Agency to Work For (2013 overall; 2016 Midwest Silver); Crain’s Cool Places to Work in Michigan |
| 9 | Marquee Insurance Group | BOOST safety monitoring program for carriers | Highway Certified Insurance Agency founding member; Express Lane client portal | Freight and factoring partnerships with DAT and OTR Solutions | Founded by freight and factoring executives | 2014 | 2.1/5.0 | $$$$ | Highway Certified founding member; DAT endorsed liability insurance partner |
| 10 | Reliance Partners | Safety consulting for trucking and freight broker clients | API-driven coverage on demand | Industry presence through trucking media and events | Privately held | 2009 | 2.5/5.0 | $$$$ | Inc. 5000 list ten times; Great Place to Work Certified |
| 11 | The Horton Group | Transportation safety programs; pre-employment strength testing | Certificate control and process services | Broad middle-market focus across many industries | Part of Marsh McLennan Agency | 1971 | Not publicly aggregated | $$ | Ranked among the 100 largest U.S. insurance brokers |
1. Truck Writers, for Risk-Managed Commercial Truck Programs
Truck Writers has written trucking insurance exclusively since 1983 and has grown into one of the largest truck insurance agencies in the Midwest. The agency remains independent and family-owned, now in its third generation of Sullivan family leadership, and every client is assigned a dedicated account team backed by a support staff of more than 30. Licensed in 38 states, it places coverage with multiple carriers and builds each program from a full review of the operation’s equipment, drivers, cargo, and loss history.
Risk management sits at the center of its service model. The trademarked Mile Markers program walks motor carriers through corporate structure, team roles, exposures, and the risk plan that best protects their assets, and clients can draw on CSA resources, safety document templates, policy and procedure worksheets, and a video library. In 2026, the agency was named one of ten founding members of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network, a commitment to certificate accuracy, VIN-level coverage transparency, and prompt policy updates for the brokers that verify carriers. Truck Writers also supports the American Trucking Associations, Women In Trucking, and trucking associations in Minnesota, Iowa, South Dakota, and Wisconsin, offers self-service per trip excess liability and cargo coverage around the clock, and serves as a licensed third-party administrator for a transportation captive and a self-insured workers’ compensation program.
Location: Blaine, MN (additional office in Welcome, MN)
Founded: 1983
Avg. Review Score: 5.0/5.0
Price Range: $$$$$
Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, workers’ compensation, transportation and freight broker bonds, per trip excess liability and cargo, owner-operator and fleet programs, captive and self-insurance programs
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently praise Truck Writers for its practical safety guidance and agents who understand how trucking businesses actually run. |
2. TrueNorth Companies, for Association-Connected Risk Consulting
TrueNorth Companies is a closely held risk management and insurance brokerage headquartered in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, with additional offices in Illinois and Colorado. Its transportation practice earned the American Trucking Associations’ Mike Russell Trucking Image Award in 2022 for its work with state trucking associations and industry nonprofits, and in 2026 the firm was named a founding member of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network. A partnership with fleet risk platform Haul adds driver and safety data to its consulting, and the firm was named a USA Today Top Workplace for the fifth straight year in 2026.
Transportation is one of several practices inside a multi-line brokerage that also serves construction, professional liability, employee benefits, and personal lines clients, so trucking is not its sole focus. Founded in 2001, it is younger than most agencies on this list, and its public client review footprint is small. Its consultative model is geared toward mid-size and larger accounts, which can leave single-truck owner-operators with fewer tailored options.
Location: Cedar Rapids, IA (additional offices in Illinois and Colorado)
Founded: 2001
Avg. Review Score: 3.9/5.0
Price Range: $$$
Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, workers’ compensation, umbrella, transportation risk consulting, employee benefits
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight TrueNorth Companies for its proactive risk consulting and knowledgeable transportation team. |
3. Cottingham & Butler, for In-House Fleet Safety and Captives
Founded in 1887 in Dubuque, Iowa, Cottingham & Butler runs one of the largest transportation insurance practices in the country, serving more than 2,500 trucking clients. Its in-house Safety Management Services Company delivers transportation safety assessments, CSA analysis, DataQ assistance, and mock OSHA and FMCSA compliance investigations. The firm has offered group captives to trucking companies since 1993, is the sole producer for the two largest transportation captives in the world, and backs its program with an in-house claims team.
Transportation is one division within a much larger firm that also serves construction, manufacturing, agribusiness, and employee benefits clients. Its captive-centered model is built for mid-size and large fleets with mature safety programs and the capital to participate, so smaller carriers may find its programs sized for operations bigger than theirs. The firm does not maintain a meaningful public client review aggregate for its transportation practice.
Location: Dubuque, IA (17 regional offices)
Founded: 1887
Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated
Price Range: $$$
Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, workers’ compensation, group captives, fleet safety services, claims management, employee benefits
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently praise Cottingham & Butler for its hands-on safety team and the long-term savings its captive programs deliver. |
4. OOIDA Truck Insurance, for Owner-Operators Who Value Advocacy
OOIDA Truck Insurance is run by the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, the Grain Valley, Missouri organization founded in 1973 that has represented independent truckers for more than five decades. The association began developing low-cost insurance products for owner-operators in the mid-1970s and reinvests insurance revenue into advocacy for small trucking businesses. In 2026, it was named a founding member of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network, and its agents bring trucking backgrounds to coverage and claims conversations.
The program is built around owner-operators and small fleets, so larger carriers will find fewer options for complex, multi-unit programs. Its risk retention group is not rated by A.M. Best, which can create acceptance issues with brokers and shippers that require a rated insurer. Beyond member compliance tools, it offers few structured loss control programs, and it does not maintain a public client review aggregate.
Location: Grain Valley, MO
Founded: 1973
Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated
Price Range: $$$$
Services: Truck liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, non-trucking liability, occupational accident, group life, association membership benefits
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight OOIDA Truck Insurance for agents who understand owner-operators and a program that stands up for truckers’ interests. |
5. Holmes Murphy, for Employee-Owned Transportation Expertise
Holmes Murphy was founded in Des Moines in 1932 by Max Holmes, and its earliest accounts came from a young trucking industry before the firm expanded across the Midwest. Now employee-owned and headquartered in Waukee, Iowa, its transportation practice writes auto liability, cargo, occupational accident, and contingent coverages, supported by customized safety and compliance audits and benchmarking data tools. Business Insurance has ranked it the No. 1 Best Place to Work in Insurance among large employers, and its founder was inducted into the Insurance Hall of Fame in 2009.
Transportation is one of many specialty practices at a large brokerage that also serves construction, agriculture, healthcare, and manufacturing clients. The firm does not publish a roster of trucking association involvement, and it has no public client review aggregate. Its middle-market orientation can make it a less natural fit for owner-operators and very small fleets.
Location: Waukee, IA
Founded: 1932
Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated
Price Range: $$$
Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, workers’ compensation, occupational accident, contingent auto and cargo, excess and umbrella, safety and compliance audits
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently praise Holmes Murphy for its strategic advice and a transportation team with real-world fleet experience. |
6. Joe Morten & Son, for Great West Casualty Access
Joe Morten & Son has served commercial trucking since 1936 and traces its roots to South Sioux City, Nebraska, where the Morten family began by helping truckers obtain operating authority. That same business gave rise to Great West Casualty Company in 1956, one of America’s largest trucking insurers, and Joe Morten & Son remains its largest agency. The agency writes liability, physical damage, cargo, workers’ compensation, and alternative risk programs, supported by its Top G.E.A.R. risk management services and loss control team.
Its deep ties to a single anchor carrier can narrow the range of competing quotes for operations that fall outside Great West’s appetite. The agency publishes little about its trucking association involvement and does not maintain a public client review aggregate. Its national, multi-office structure also means clients work through a larger organization rather than a single local team.
Location: South Sioux City, NE
Founded: 1936
Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated
Price Range: $$$$
Services: Truck liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, umbrella, workers’ compensation, alternative risk programs, Top G.E.A.R. risk management, loss control
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight Joe Morten & Son for its long-standing trucking expertise and dependable service. |
7. Marvin Johnson & Associates, for Indiana, Ohio, and Illinois Carriers
Marvin Johnson founded the agency in Columbus, Indiana, in 1971, and three generations later it has grown into the largest independent truck insurance agency in Indiana, Ohio, and Illinois. The family-owned firm provides safety services, accident packets, and bond and permit services as conveniences for its trucking clients, and it promotes their interests through the trucking associations it is affiliated with. Acuity Insurance profiled the agency at its 50th anniversary, highlighting a service philosophy built on the Golden Rule.
Its footprint centers on Indiana, Ohio, and Illinois, so carriers based further west may find fewer local resources. The agency also writes home, auto, and general business coverage, which means trucking is a core specialty rather than its only line, and captive or self-insurance programs are not part of its public offering. Its online review presence is limited to an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.
Location: Columbus, IN (additional office in the Akron, OH area)
Founded: 1971
Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated (BBB A+)
Price Range: $$$$
Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, workers’ compensation, bonds and permits, safety services, accident packets
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight Marvin Johnson & Associates for its prompt, personal service and agents who know the trucking business. |
8. Kapnick Insurance, for Towing and Transportation Operators
Kapnick Insurance was founded in Adrian, Michigan, in 1946 and remains a family-owned, privately held firm with offices in Adrian, Ann Arbor, Troy, and Grand Rapids. Its transportation and towing practice pairs risk management advisory with client executives who know the towing community, and the firm has added specialists to extend its transportation service into Minnesota and Wisconsin. Insurance Journal named Kapnick its Best Agency to Work For overall in 2013, and it has also been recognized among Crain’s Cool Places to Work in Michigan.
Employee benefits make up a large share of its business, so trucking is one specialty among many rather than the firm’s focus. Its transportation practice leans toward towing, which may leave long-haul carriers with fewer specialized resources, and its public client reviews average 3.0 across listings. It publishes little about involvement with state trucking associations.
Location: Adrian, MI (additional offices in Ann Arbor, Troy, and Grand Rapids)
Founded: 1946
Avg. Review Score: 3.0/5.0
Price Range: $$$
Services: Commercial auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, towing operations coverage, workers’ compensation, risk management advisory, employee benefits
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently praise Kapnick Insurance for its knowledgeable towing specialists and responsive client executives. |
9. Marquee Insurance Group, for Load Board-Connected Carriers
Marquee Insurance Group was founded in Roswell, Georgia, in 2014 by an ownership team with roots in freight brokerage and factoring, including Nolan Transportation Group and OTR Solutions. The trucking-only agency shops coverage across more than 30 A-rated markets, serves as DAT’s endorsed liability insurance partner, and supports carriers with its Express Lane portal and BOOST safety monitoring program. In 2026, it was named a founding member of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network, and it actively helps new authorities through their first year.
As one of the youngest agencies on this list, Marquee has a shorter track record through hard insurance markets. Its public client reviews are limited and average 2.1 on the Better Business Bureau. Its industry ties run through freight and factoring partnerships rather than trucking associations.
Location: Roswell, GA
Founded: 2014
Avg. Review Score: 2.1/5.0
Price Range: $$$$
Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, new authority programs, fleet insurance, owner-operator insurance, safety monitoring
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight Marquee Insurance Group for agents who go above and beyond to find competitive rates for small trucking companies. |
10. Reliance Partners, for Freight Broker and Cross-Border Coverage
Reliance Partners was founded in Chattanooga, Tennessee, in 2009 by logistics entrepreneurs and focuses on trucking, freight brokerage, and logistics insurance. The firm offers specialty USMCA programs for carriers that need liability and cargo coverage in Canada and Mexico, along with API-driven coverage on demand for customized needs. It earned its tenth Inc. 5000 ranking in 2026, has been Great Place to Work Certified, and grew from about $95 million in written premium in 2018 to nearly $500 million by 2023.
Its rapid growth has come with mixed client feedback, and its Trustpilot rating averages 2.5 across a small number of reviews. The firm publishes little about structured loss control programs or trucking association involvement. Its national, technology-driven model may also feel less personal to carriers that want a single local agent.
Location: Chattanooga, TN
Founded: 2009
Avg. Review Score: 2.5/5.0
Price Range: $$$$
Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, bobtail and non-trucking liability, excess and umbrella, workers’ compensation, freight broker insurance, cross-border coverage
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight Reliance Partners for agents with real expertise in trucking and freight brokerage. |
11. The Horton Group, for Middle-Market Fleets Seeking a Large Broker
The Horton Group began in 1971 as an eight-person agency in Orland Park, Illinois, and grew into one of the largest brokers in the Chicago area, consistently ranked among the 100 largest U.S. brokers. Its business insurance practice serves transportation, warehousing, and logistics clients with transportation safety programs, certificate control, surety bonds, and captive options. The firm serves clients from offices across Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Florida.
Horton is now part of Marsh McLennan Agency, so strategic decisions sit within a national consolidator rather than with an independent local owner. Transportation is one of many industry practices at a middle-market firm, and its moving and storage program is limited to operations with more than 20 trucks. It has no public client review aggregate and publishes little about trucking association involvement.
Location: Orland Park, IL
Founded: 1971
Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated
Price Range: $$
Services: Commercial auto, physical damage, cargo, workers’ compensation, transportation safety programs, certificate control, surety bonds, captives, employee benefits
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently praise The Horton Group for its deep bench of resources and the tools it brings to every account. |
The Best Insurance Agencies for Commercial Trucks by Specialty
We also broke down the top commercial truck insurance agencies into three subcategories based on common buyer priorities.
The Best Commercial Truck Insurance Agencies for Broker and Shipper Verification
- Truck Writers
- TrueNorth Companies
- Marquee Insurance Group
- OOIDA Truck Insurance
- The Horton Group
The Best Commercial Truck Insurance Agencies for Upper Midwest Carriers (MN, WI, IA, ND, SD)
- Truck Writers
- TrueNorth Companies
- Cottingham & Butler
- Holmes Murphy
- Joe Morten & Son
The Best Commercial Truck Insurance Agencies for Owner-Operators (1 to 5 Trucks)
- OOIDA Truck Insurance
- Truck Writers
- Marquee Insurance Group
- Marvin Johnson & Associates
- Reliance Partners
How to Choose the Best Insurance Agency for Your Commercial Trucks
The best insurance agency for a commercial truck depends on fleet size, hauling territory, how often brokers verify your coverage, and how much safety support the operation needs between renewals. The agencies on this list cover that full range, from association-backed programs for single-truck owner-operators to captive programs for large fleets with mature safety cultures.
Truck Writers ranked first because of what it combines: more than four decades of trucking-only focus, three generations of independent family ownership, a trademarked risk management program backed by CSA, safety, and policy resources, and founding membership in Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network. Add active support for national and state trucking associations, multi-carrier pricing, and around-the-clock per trip excess coverage, and commercial truck owners get an agency that protects the operation long after the policy is bound.
Ready to insure yourself with an agency built around commercial trucking? Feel free to request a quote from Truck Writers.