The Best Cargo Insurance Agencies: A 2026 Review

Close-up of a silver semi-truck cab and headlights at sunset

From August through October 2026, our research team evaluated insurance agencies that place cargo coverage for trucking and logistics businesses across the United States, with an emphasis on agencies headquartered or highly active in the Midwest. We focused on agencies that write motor truck cargo for carriers and related cargo coverages for the brokers, forwarders, and shippers that hand freight off to them. Each agency was scored using a seven-factor algorithm. The table that follows compares the ten top-performing cargo insurance agencies; then, subsequently, in-depth reviews of each.

  • Freight Custody Chain Coverage (22%): Freight changes hands several times between pickup and delivery, so agencies that can insure the carrier, the broker, and the freight in storage or interchange close the gaps where cargo claims fall through.
  • Per-Load Cargo Limit Flexibility (20%): Agencies that can raise a cargo limit for a single high-value load let carriers accept better-paying freight without paying for a higher limit all year.
  • Cargo Coverage Education (15%): Cargo policies vary more than any other trucking coverage, so agencies that publish clear guidance on limits, exclusions, and broker requirements help buyers avoid denied claims.
  • Average Review Score (13%): Client ratings from the BBB, Birdeye, Trustpilot, and similar platforms, averaged where an agency appears on more than one, show how consistently an agency delivers on its promises.
  • Year Founded (10%): Longevity signals deep carrier relationships, claims experience, and staying power through multiple hard insurance markets.
  • Price Range (10%): Rated from $ (least flexible) to $$$$$ (most flexible), this reflects how well an agency can fit cargo coverage to different budgets through carrier access and the range of operations it prices for.
  • Awards and Recognition (10%): Industry, carrier, and workplace honors offer third-party validation of an agency’s standing.
Rank Agency Freight Custody Chain Coverage Per-Load Cargo Limit Flexibility Cargo Coverage Education Avg. Review Score Year Founded Price Range Awards & Recognition
1 Truck Writers Motor truck cargo for owner-operators and fleets; per trip excess cargo for carriers, brokers, and forwarders; cargo, bailee, and trailer interchange liability in an administered captive Self-service per trip excess cargo up to $1M over underlying limits, available 24/7/365 Published guides on per-load cargo, broker cargo exposure, and standard cargo limits 5.0/5.0 1983 $$$$$ Highway Certified Insurance Agency founding member (2026); profiled by Acuity Insurance for three generations of family-focused success
2 Roanoke Insurance Group Shipper’s interest, cargo legal liability, contingent cargo, motor truck cargo, and warehouse and bailee coverage Shipper’s interest cargo structured by shipment, trade lane, and commodity Cargo Insurance Essentials eBook and Knowledgeport online training platform Not publicly aggregated 1935 $$$ First U.S. customs import bond provider; first appointed ATA Carnet provider in the U.S.
3 Reliance Partners Motor truck cargo, contingent cargo for brokers, shipper’s interest, trailer interchange, LTL, and cross-border cargo Usage-based per-load cargo that lifts a $100,000 carrier limit as high as $10M; API access inside TMS platforms Blog and industry media coverage on usage-based and shipper’s interest cargo 2.5/5.0 2009 $$$$ Inc. 5000 list ten times; Great Place to Work Certified
4 Cottingham & Butler Motor truck cargo, warehouse legal liability, and cargo inside trucking captive programs Annual and revenue-based blanket cargo policies Transportation Monthly newsletter covering cargo sub-limits, reefer breakdown, and warehouse liability Not publicly aggregated 1887 $$$ Sole producer for the two largest transportation captives in the world
5 TrueNorth Companies Cargo for own-authority carriers, cargo legal liability for final-mile contractors, and contingent cargo guidance for brokers Limits set at annual renewal Blog guidance on cargo risk transfer for brokers and preventing cargo theft 3.9/5.0 2001 $$$ ATA Mike Russell Trucking Image Award (2022); USA Today Top Workplace (2026); Highway Certified founding member
6 Holmes Murphy Motor truck cargo, contingent cargo, contingent auto, and E&O for logistics firms Limits set at annual renewal Trucking insurance FAQ library Not publicly aggregated 1932 $$$ Business Insurance No. 1 Best Place to Work in Insurance; founder inducted into the Insurance Hall of Fame
7 Marquee Insurance Group Motor truck cargo for carriers, including tow and debris cleanup coverage Per Shipment Cargo excess coverage for specific loads New Authority Guide and MIG blog 2.1/5.0 2014 $$$$ Highway Certified founding member; DAT endorsed insurance partner
8 Joe Morten & Son Motor truck cargo for carriers through Great West Casualty Limits set at annual renewal Limited published cargo guidance Not publicly aggregated 1936 $$$$ Largest agency of Great West Casualty Company
9 OOIDA Truck Insurance Motor truck cargo and trailer interchange for owner-operators Limits set at annual renewal Insurance department columns in trucking media Not publicly aggregated 1973 $$$$ Highway Certified founding member (2026)
10 Marvin Johnson & Associates Motor truck cargo for carriers, with bond and permit services Limits set at annual renewal Limited published cargo guidance Not publicly aggregated (BBB A+) 1971 $$$$ Profiled by Acuity Insurance at its 50th anniversary; largest independent truck insurance agency in Indiana, Ohio, and Illinois

1. Truck Writers, for Cargo Coverage at Every Hand-Off

Truck Writers has written trucking insurance exclusively since 1983 and has grown into one of the largest truck insurance agencies in the Midwest. The agency remains independent and family-owned, now in its third generation of Sullivan family leadership, and every client is assigned a dedicated account team backed by a support staff of more than 30. As an independent agency, it places motor truck cargo with multiple carriers for single-unit owner-operators and multi-truck fleets alike, building each program around the commodities, lanes, and loss history of the operation.

Where Truck Writers separates itself is the reach of its cargo program. Through TripExcess, it offers A-rated, self-service per trip excess cargo of up to $1,000,000 over an existing cargo policy, available around the clock to motor carriers, freight brokers, and freight forwarders, so a carrier with a standard $100,000 cargo limit can book a higher-value load in minutes. The agency is also a licensed third-party administrator for a transportation captive whose coverages include cargo, bailee, and trailer interchange liability, and it publishes practical guides on per-load cargo, broker cargo exposure, and the cargo limits shippers and brokers typically require. In 2026, it was named one of ten founding members of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network, a commitment to accurate certificates and prompt policy updates for the brokers that verify carriers.

Location: Blaine, MN (additional office in Welcome, MN)

Founded: 1983

Avg. Review Score: 5.0/5.0

Price Range: $$$$$

Services: Motor truck cargo, per trip excess cargo and liability, auto liability, physical damage, general liability, workers’ compensation, freight broker bonds and coverage, owner-operator and fleet programs, captive and self-insurance programs

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients consistently praise Truck Writers for its responsive account teams and for making it easy to add cargo coverage the moment a load calls for it.

2. Roanoke Insurance Group, for Freight Forwarders and Logistics Intermediaries

Roanoke Insurance Group has specialized in insurance and surety for the logistics and trade industry since 1935, and today operates from Schaumburg, Illinois, as part of Munich Re. Its cargo lineup is one of the broadest available to transportation intermediaries, covering shipper’s interest, cargo legal liability, contingent cargo, motor truck cargo, and warehouse and bailee exposures. Roanoke was the first provider of U.S. customs import bonds and the first appointed ATA Carnet provider in the country, and it supports clients with its Cargo Insurance Essentials eBook and the Knowledgeport online training platform.

Roanoke’s book is built around freight forwarders, customs brokers, NVOCCs, and companies managing global supply chains, so asset-based motor carriers are not its primary audience. Its programs lean toward international and multimodal trade rather than domestic truckload operations, and it does not offer the auto liability, physical damage, and workers’ compensation lines a trucking company needs alongside cargo. It also has no meaningful public client review aggregate.

Location: Schaumburg, IL

Founded: 1935

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated

Price Range: $$$

Services: Shipper’s interest cargo, cargo legal liability, contingent cargo, motor truck cargo, warehouse and bailee liability, customs bonds, ATA Carnets, transportation professional liability, surety bonds

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight Roanoke Insurance Group for its deep cargo expertise and the training resources it shares with logistics teams.

3. Reliance Partners, for Occasional High-Value Loads

Reliance Partners was founded in Chattanooga, Tennessee, in 2009 and focuses on trucking, freight brokerage, and logistics insurance. Its usage-based insurance program lets carriers, brokers, and shippers buy primary and excess cargo on a per-load basis, so a carrier with a $100,000 cargo limit can pull loads valued up to $10 million when needed. Reliance integrates per-load shipper’s interest coverage directly into transportation management systems such as McLeod, writes contingent cargo and trailer interchange, and has earned ten Inc. 5000 rankings.

Its rapid growth has come with mixed client feedback, and its Trustpilot rating averages 2.5 across a small number of reviews. Founded in 2009, it is younger than most agencies on this list, with a shorter track record through hard cargo markets. Its national, technology-driven model may also feel less personal to carriers that want a single local agent who knows their operation.

Location: Chattanooga, TN

Founded: 2009

Avg. Review Score: 2.5/5.0

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Motor truck cargo, usage-based primary and excess cargo, shipper’s interest, contingent cargo, trailer interchange, auto liability, physical damage, freight broker insurance, cross-border coverage

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight Reliance Partners for how quickly it can add cargo coverage to a high-value load.

4. Cottingham & Butler, for Large Fleets in Captive Programs

Founded in 1887 in Dubuque, Iowa, Cottingham & Butler runs one of the largest transportation insurance practices in the country, serving more than 2,500 trucking companies. Its transportation group writes motor truck cargo alongside auto liability, physical damage, and workers’ compensation, and it can place cargo inside the trucking captives it has pioneered for more than 30 years. Its Transportation Monthly newsletter has covered cargo sub-limits, reefer breakdown coverage, and warehouse legal liability, and an in-house claims team advocates for clients after a loss.

Cargo is written on annual or revenue-based blanket policies, with no published option for raising a limit on a single load. Its captive-centered model is built for mid-size and large fleets with mature safety programs, so smaller carriers may find its programs sized for operations bigger than theirs. The firm does not maintain a public client review aggregate for its transportation practice.

Location: Dubuque, IA (17 regional offices)

Founded: 1887

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated

Price Range: $$$

Services: Motor truck cargo, auto liability, physical damage, general liability, workers’ compensation, umbrella, group captives, fleet safety services, claims management

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients consistently praise Cottingham & Butler for its knowledgeable transportation team and the long-term value of its captive programs.

5. TrueNorth Companies, for Cargo Theft Awareness

TrueNorth Companies is a closely held risk management and insurance brokerage headquartered in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. Its transportation division writes cargo for own-authority carriers and cargo legal liability for final-mile contract carriers, and it publishes guidance on cargo risk transfer for freight brokers and on preventing cargo theft. TrueNorth earned the American Trucking Associations’ Mike Russell Trucking Image Award in 2022 and was named a founding member of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network in 2026.

Cargo limits are set at annual renewal, and the firm does not publish a per-load option for high-value freight. Transportation is one of several practices inside a multi-line brokerage that also serves construction, employee benefits, and personal lines clients. Founded in 2001, it is younger than most agencies on this list, and its public client review footprint is small.

Location: Cedar Rapids, IA (additional offices in Illinois and Colorado)

Founded: 2001

Avg. Review Score: 3.9/5.0

Price Range: $$$

Services: Motor truck cargo, cargo legal liability, auto liability, physical damage, general liability, workers’ compensation, occupational accident, umbrella, transportation risk consulting

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight TrueNorth Companies for its proactive advice on protecting freight from theft.

6. Holmes Murphy, for Logistics Firms Needing Contingent Cargo

Holmes Murphy was founded in Des Moines in 1932, and its earliest accounts came from a young trucking industry before the firm expanded across the Midwest. Now employee-owned and headquartered in Waukee, Iowa, its transportation practice writes motor truck cargo for carriers along with contingent cargo, contingent auto, and errors and omissions coverage for freight brokers and logistics companies. Business Insurance has ranked it the No. 1 Best Place to Work in Insurance among large employers, and its founder was inducted into the Insurance Hall of Fame.

Transportation is one of many specialty practices at a large brokerage that also serves construction, agriculture, healthcare, and manufacturing clients. Cargo limits are set at annual renewal, with no published per-load option, and its published cargo guidance is limited to a general trucking FAQ. Its middle-market orientation can make it a less natural fit for owner-operators, and it has no public client review aggregate.

Location: Waukee, IA

Founded: 1932

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated

Price Range: $$$

Services: Motor truck cargo, contingent cargo, contingent auto, auto liability, physical damage, general liability, workers’ compensation, occupational accident, cyber liability, E&O, excess and umbrella

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients consistently praise Holmes Murphy for its strategic advice and a transportation team that understands logistics risk.

7. Marquee Insurance Group, for New Authorities

Marquee Insurance Group was founded in Roswell, Georgia, in 2014 by an ownership team with roots in freight brokerage and factoring. The trucking-only agency writes motor truck cargo for carriers and offers Per Shipment Cargo, an excess line of coverage for specific loads. It serves as DAT’s endorsed commercial insurance partner, publishes a New Authority Guide for carriers in their first year, and was named a founding member of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network in 2026.

As one of the youngest agencies on this list, Marquee has a shorter track record through hard cargo markets. Its cargo program centers on motor carriers, with fewer options for brokers, forwarders, or freight in storage. Its public client reviews are limited and average 2.1 on the Better Business Bureau.

Location: Roswell, GA

Founded: 2014

Avg. Review Score: 2.1/5.0

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Motor truck cargo, Per Shipment Cargo, auto liability, physical damage, general liability, bobtail, workers’ compensation, occupational accident, surety bonds, new authority programs

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight Marquee Insurance Group for agents who go above and beyond to help new carriers get insured and on the road.

8. Joe Morten & Son, for Great West Casualty Access

Joe Morten & Son has served commercial trucking since 1936 and traces its roots to South Sioux City, Nebraska, where the Morten family began by helping truckers navigate insurance regulations. It is the largest agency of Great West Casualty Company, one of the country’s largest trucking insurers, and serves more than 9,000 customers from service locations across the country. The agency writes cargo alongside liability, workers’ compensation, and alternative risk programs, supported by risk management and loss control services.

Its deep ties to a single anchor carrier can narrow the range of competing cargo quotes for operations that fall outside Great West’s appetite. Cargo limits are set at annual renewal, with no published per-load option, and the agency publishes little cargo-specific guidance. It does not maintain a public client review aggregate.

Location: South Sioux City, NE

Founded: 1936

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Motor truck cargo, truck liability, physical damage, general liability, workers’ compensation, alternative risk programs, risk management, loss control

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight Joe Morten & Son for its long-standing trucking expertise and dependable service.

9. OOIDA Truck Insurance, for Owner-Operators Who Value Advocacy

OOIDA Truck Insurance is run by the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, the Grain Valley, Missouri organization founded in 1973 that has represented independent truckers for more than five decades. It writes motor truck cargo, trailer interchange, and physical damage for owner-operators running under their own authority, with monthly installments and no added finance costs. Members of its insurance department write regular columns in trucking media explaining what common policies do and do not cover.

The program is built around owner-operators and small fleets, so larger carriers, brokers, and forwarders will find fewer cargo options. Cargo limits are set at annual renewal, with no published per-load option for high-value freight. It does not maintain a public client review aggregate.

Location: Grain Valley, MO

Founded: 1973

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Motor truck cargo, primary liability, general liability, physical damage, trailer interchange, non-trucking liability, roadside breakdown, occupational accident

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight OOIDA Truck Insurance for agents who understand owner-operators and explain coverage in plain terms.

10. Marvin Johnson & Associates, for Indiana, Ohio, and Illinois Carriers

Marvin Johnson founded the agency in Columbus, Indiana, in 1971, and three generations later it has grown into the largest independent truck insurance agency in Indiana, Ohio, and Illinois. The family-owned firm writes cargo alongside liability and workers’ compensation and provides safety services, accident packets, and bond and permit services as conveniences for its trucking clients. Acuity Insurance profiled the agency at its 50th anniversary, highlighting a service philosophy built on the Golden Rule.

Its footprint centers on Indiana, Ohio, and Illinois, so carriers based further west may find fewer local resources. Its cargo offering focuses on motor carriers, with no published per-load option or broker cargo program, and it publishes little cargo-specific guidance. Its online review presence is limited to an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.

Location: Columbus, IN (additional office in the Akron, OH area)

Founded: 1971

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated (BBB A+)

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Motor truck cargo, auto liability, physical damage, workers’ compensation, bonds and permits, safety services, accident packets

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight Marvin Johnson & Associates for its prompt, personal service and agents who know the trucking business.

The Best Cargo Insurance Agencies by Specialty

We also broke down the top cargo insurance agencies into three subcategories based on common buyer priorities.

The Best for Carriers That Also Broker Freight

  1. Truck Writers
  2. Reliance Partners
  3. Roanoke Insurance Group
  4. Holmes Murphy
  5. TrueNorth Companies

The Best for Growing Fleets (5 to 25 Power Units)

  1. Truck Writers
  2. Cottingham & Butler
  3. Joe Morten & Son
  4. TrueNorth Companies
  5. Marvin Johnson & Associates

The Best for Occasional High-Value Loads

  1. Reliance Partners
  2. Truck Writers
  3. Roanoke Insurance Group
  4. Marquee Insurance Group
  5. Cottingham & Butler

How to Choose the Best Cargo Insurance Agency

The best cargo insurance agency depends on what you haul, who you haul it for, and how often a load’s value runs past your standard limit. The agencies on this list cover that full range, from association-backed cargo programs for single-truck owner-operators to captive programs for large fleets and specialty cargo lines for freight forwarders and logistics intermediaries.

Ready to protect every load with an agency built around trucking? Request a Cargo Insurance Quote from Truck Writers

Sources

Blaine, MN

8970 West 35W Service Dr. NE
Suite 200
Blaine, MN 55449

Welcome, MN

605 North Guide Street
Welcome, MN 56181

Also, providing service in Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, North Dakota, South Dakota and nationwide.