Best Small Fleet Insurance Agencies – 2026

A white semi-truck pulling a trailer on a highway under a blue sky

From September through November 2026, our research team evaluated independent agencies and brokers that write small fleet trucking insurance. We drew on agency websites, carrier and trade publications, trucking association materials, press releases, the Better Business Bureau, Birdeye, Google and Trustpilot, then scored each agency on a scale from 1 to 10 with the eight weighted factors below. The weighted scores were then combined into a single composite score, further laid out in detail by the table.

  • Operation-Specific Program Design (20%): We weighted this most heavily because a small fleet’s lanes, freight, drivers and equipment drive its premium, and an agency that studies the operation before quoting builds a program that fits rather than one that merely complies.
  • Leased Owner-Operator Program Support (18%): Many small fleets add capacity by leasing on owner-operators, so we measured how well each agency handles occupational accident, non-trucking liability and physical damage for those contractors.
  • Cost Transparency and Buyer Education (15%): Small fleet owners usually manage insurance themselves, so we credited agencies that publish cost benchmarks, plain-language guides and answers that help owners budget before they request a quote.
  • Growth-Stage Risk Financing Access (15%): We rewarded agencies that give smaller carriers a realistic route into captives or group self-insurance, because that route is how a growing fleet gains long-term control over its insurance costs.
  • Year Founded (9%): Longevity in trucking insurance signals carrier relationships and market knowledge that survive hard insurance cycles.
  • Average Review Score (10%): We averaged client ratings across Google, Birdeye, Trustpilot, Yelp, Facebook and the Better Business Bureau where available, and scored agencies with no public client aggregate as neutral.
  • Price Range (7%): We rated pricing flexibility from $ (least flexible) to $$$$$ (most flexible), based on carrier access, program options and the ability to fit coverage to a tight small fleet budget.
  • Awards and Recognition (6%): Industry, carrier and workplace honors add third-party validation of an agency’s reputation.
Rank Agency Program Design Approach Leased Owner-Operator Support Cost Transparency Growth-Stage Risk Financing Year Founded Avg. Review Score Price Range Awards & Recognition
1 Truck Writers Agents analyze each fleet operation before building a program; trucking-only staff Owner-operator fleet programs; occupational accident; non-trucking liability and bobtail in 38 states Publishes 2026 fleet and owner-operator cost benchmarks, buyer guides and a public FAQ Licensed TPA for a rent-a-captive (TARP) and a trucking workers’ comp self-insurance group (MSG) 1983 5.0/5.0 $$$$$ Highway Certified founding member (2026); Acuity agency feature
2 TrueNorth Companies Consultative transportation team with safety, claims and data tools TrueChoices and Independent Advantage contractor platforms; occupational accident; non-trucking liability Transportation blog and webinars; no published premium benchmarks Captive and alternative risk options for transportation clients 2001 3.9/5.0 $$$ ATA Trucking Image Award (2022); Highway Certified founding member; USA Today Top Workplaces
3 Cottingham & Butler In-house safety benchmarking and driver risk evaluation Contractor coverage through its transportation group Safety content; little public pricing guidance Leading group trucking captive provider; $159M+ in dividends returned to members 1887 Not publicly aggregated $$ Ranked among the largest privately held U.S. brokers
4 Joe Morten & Son Top G.E.A.R. risk management and loss control services Owner-operator programs; occupational accident Limited public cost guidance Alternative risk programs alongside its anchor carrier 1936 Not publicly aggregated $$$$ Largest Great West Casualty agency
5 OOIDA Truck Insurance Standardized member program for single trucks and small fleets Three occupational accident plan limits; non-trucking liability; physical damage Member education through OOIDA and Land Line Member-owned risk retention group 1973 Not publicly aggregated $$$$ Highway Certified founding member (2026)
6 Reliance Partners Freight-focused agents serving single trucks to 1,000-unit fleets Occupational accident; non-trucking liability; bobtail Large public library of coverage guides and articles Alternative risk options geared to larger fleets 2009 2.3/5.0 $$$$ Inc. 5000 honoree in multiple years
7 RJS Truck Insurance Multi-carrier quoting fitted to hauling radius, cargo and driver history Bobtail; non-trucking liability; occupational accident Basic coverage FAQs No captive or self-insurance program 1992 4.9/5.0 $$$$ None publicly listed
8 Marvin Johnson & Associates Trucking-built claims process and safety services Owner-operator and fleet coverage Limited public cost guidance No public captive or self-insurance program 1971 Not publicly aggregated $$$$ Acuity agency feature
9 Marquee Insurance Group Express Lane portal and BOOST safety monitoring Owner-operator and leased driver coverage Education-first approach with public trucking insurance guides Limited alternative risk options 2014 2.1/5.0 $$$$ DAT endorsed liability partner; Highway Certified founding member; Atlanta Pacesetter
10 Aronson Group Technology-driven quoting built for 1 to 9 unit fleets Owner-operator coverage; few contractor-specific programs Plain-language online guidance and fast quotes No captive or self-insurance program 2017 4.9/5.0 $$$$ None publicly listed
11 Kapnick Insurance Risk management advisory with towing and transportation specialists Limited owner-operator programs General business insurance content Alternative risk advice through its commercial practice 1946 3.0/5.0 $$$ Insurance Journal Best Agency to Work For; Crain’s Cool Places to Work

1. Truck Writers, for Operation-Specific Small Fleet Programs

Truck Writers has written trucking insurance exclusively since Donald and Bonnie Sullivan opened the agency in 1983, and it remains independent and family-owned with the third generation now in the business. Before quoting, its agents analyze how a small fleet actually runs, including lanes, freight, drivers and equipment, then build a program around those risks rather than forcing the operation into a template. Every client gets a dedicated account team backed by more than 30 support staff, and the agency shops a large roster of carriers to find the best fit and price for each operation.

That approach carries through a fleet’s growth. Truck Writers writes owner-operator fleet programs, occupational accident, and non-trucking liability and bobtail coverage in 38 states for fleets that add capacity by leasing on contractors. It publishes its own 2026 cost benchmarks and buyer guides so owners can budget before they shop, offers self-service per trip excess liability and cargo coverage around the clock, and serves as a licensed third-party administrator for the TARP rent-a-captive and the Midwest Safety Group workers’ compensation self-insurance program. In 2026, Highway named Truck Writers one of 10 founding members of its Certified Insurance Agency network.

Location: Blaine, MN (additional office in Welcome, MN)

Founded: 1983

Avg. Review Score: 5.0/5.0

Price Range: $$$$$

Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, workers’ compensation, occupational accident, non-trucking liability and bobtail, per trip excess liability and cargo, transportation and freight broker bonds, owner-operator and fleet programs, captive and self-insurance programs

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients consistently praise Truck Writers for agents who take the time to learn their operation and a dedicated account team that answers when they call.

2. TrueNorth Companies, for Fleets Built on Independent Contractors

TrueNorth Companies is a risk management and insurance brokerage headquartered in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, with a nationally recognized transportation practice. Its independent contractor platforms, including TrueChoices and Independent Advantage, give motor carriers a way to offer occupational accident, non-trucking liability, physical damage and personal benefits to leased owner-operators without taking on misclassification risk. The firm earned the American Trucking Associations’ Trucking Image Award in 2022, was named one of 10 founding members of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network in 2026, and has been recognized as a USA Today Top Workplace.

Transportation is one of several practices inside a multi-line brokerage that also serves construction, employee benefits and personal lines clients. Its independent contractor programs were built around large asset-light carriers, so a fleet of five or ten trucks may not get the same level of attention. The firm publishes little on what small fleets should expect to pay, and its public client review footprint is small, averaging 3.9 on Birdeye.

Location: Cedar Rapids, IA (additional offices in Illinois and Colorado)

Founded: 2001

Avg. Review Score: 3.9/5.0

Price Range: $$$

Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, workers’ compensation, occupational accident, non-trucking liability, independent contractor benefits, captive and alternative risk programs, transportation risk consulting

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight TrueNorth Companies for its deep transportation expertise and the support it gives carriers working with independent contractors.

3. Cottingham & Butler, for Fleets Headed Toward a Group Captive

Founded in Dubuque, Iowa, in 1887, Cottingham & Butler runs one of the largest transportation insurance practices in the country, serving more than 2,500 trucking clients. It pioneered group trucking captives more than 25 years ago and reports returning more than $159 million in dividends to captive members, with average member retention of 99%. Its in-house Safety Management Services Company provides safety program benchmarking and driver risk evaluation, and its claims services arm acts as a trucking-focused third-party administrator.

Its captive programs and consulting model are designed around mid-size and larger motor carriers, so a fleet of a few trucks may find its processes heavier than it needs. The firm publishes little public guidance on small fleet pricing, and it has no meaningful public client review aggregate. Employee benefits and other commercial lines make up a significant share of its business beyond trucking.

Location: Dubuque, IA

Founded: 1887

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated

Price Range: $$

Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, workers’ compensation, group captives, safety and loss control services, claims administration, employee benefits

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients consistently praise Cottingham & Butler for its strong captive programs and a safety team that knows trucking.

4. Joe Morten & Son, for Established Great West Casualty Access

Joe Morten & Son has served commercial trucking since 1936 and traces its roots to South Sioux City, Nebraska, where it grew alongside Great West Casualty Company and remains that carrier’s largest agency. The agency writes liability, physical damage, cargo, workers’ compensation, owner-operator and occupational accident coverage from offices in Nebraska, Iowa, Illinois, Colorado and other states. Its Top G.E.A.R. risk management services and loss control team help fleets improve safety performance and operating efficiency.

Its deep ties to a single anchor carrier can narrow the range of competing quotes for small fleets that fall outside that carrier’s appetite. The agency publishes little cost guidance for owners who want to budget before they shop. It does not maintain a public client review aggregate.

Location: South Sioux City, NE (additional offices in Iowa, Illinois, Colorado and other states)

Founded: 1936

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Truck liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, workers’ compensation, occupational accident, owner-operator programs, alternative risk programs, Top G.E.A.R. risk management services

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight Joe Morten & Son for its trucking knowledge and the long-term relationships its agents build.

5. OOIDA Truck Insurance, for Association-Backed Owner-Operator Fleets

The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association began offering truck insurance in 1973 to give small trucking businesses an alternative to expensive and unreliable coverage. Based in Grain Valley, Missouri, its program covers truck liability, physical damage and non-trucking liability, and it sponsors three occupational accident plan limits for owner-operators and drivers not required to carry workers’ compensation. In 2026, OOIDA was named one of 10 founding members of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network.

Coverage requires OOIDA membership and follows a standardized member program, which leaves less room to tailor coverage to a specific fleet’s operation. Its liability coverage runs through a risk retention group that is not rated by A.M. Best, which can create acceptance issues with brokers and shippers that require a rated insurer. The program is built first for single trucks, so fleets adding employed drivers and more units may outgrow it.

Location: Grain Valley, MO

Founded: 1973

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Truck liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, non-trucking liability, occupational accident, life and health benefits for members

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight OOIDA Truck Insurance for a program that understands owner-operators and stands up for truckers’ interests.

6. Reliance Partners, for Freight-Savvy Coverage Guidance

Reliance Partners was founded in 2009 in Chattanooga, Tennessee, by a team with roots in freight brokerage, and it now insures operations ranging from a single truck to fleets of a thousand units. The agency writes trucking, warehousing and freight broker coverage, including occupational accident, non-trucking liability and bobtail for contractors. It maintains one of the larger public libraries of trucking insurance articles and guides in the industry and has been named to the Inc. 5000 list of fast-growing private companies many times.

Its public client reviews are limited and average 2.3 on Trustpilot, with some small carriers reporting inconsistent communication at renewal. Its national, high-volume model can feel less personal to an owner who wants a single local agent who knows the operation. Alternative risk options are geared mostly to larger fleets.

Location: Chattanooga, TN

Founded: 2009

Avg. Review Score: 2.3/5.0

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, bobtail and non-trucking liability, occupational accident, workers’ compensation, warehousing coverage, freight broker insurance

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight Reliance Partners for agents with real expertise in trucking and freight brokerage.

7. RJS Truck Insurance, for Highly Rated Personal Service

RJS Truck Insurance has operated out of Laguna Niguel, California, since 1992 and has built the strongest verified service reputation in this comparison, averaging 4.9 across Google and Birdeye with hundreds of client reviews. The agency shops multiple carriers and matches coverage to each client’s hauling radius, cargo type, authority status and driving history. Its coverage lines include primary auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, bobtail, non-trucking liability, occupational accident and general liability.

RJS is a smaller agency without a captive or self-insurance program, so a growing fleet has no built-in path into risk financing as it adds trucks. It publishes little in the way of cost benchmarks or small fleet budgeting guidance. Its West Coast base also puts it farther from Midwest fleets that prefer a regional agency.

Location: Laguna Niguel, CA

Founded: 1992

Avg. Review Score: 4.9/5.0

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, bobtail, non-trucking liability, occupational accident, general liability

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients consistently praise RJS Truck Insurance for fast responses and agents who go above and beyond to get coverage in place.

8. Marvin Johnson & Associates, for Indiana, Ohio and Illinois Fleets

Marvin Johnson & Associates was founded in 1971 in Columbus, Indiana, and has grown into one of the largest independent truck insurance agencies in Indiana, Ohio and Illinois, with an additional office in the Akron, Ohio area. Its claims process is built around trucking, and its team supports clients with safety services, accident packets, bonds and permits. The agency holds an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.

The agency also writes home, auto and general business coverage, so trucking is a core specialty rather than its only line. It does not publicly offer captive or self-insurance programs, and it publishes little cost guidance for small fleet owners. Its strength is concentrated in a three-state core, which can limit fit for fleets running farther west.

Location: Columbus, IN (additional office in the Akron, OH area)

Founded: 1971

Avg. Review Score: Not publicly aggregated (BBB A+)

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, workers’ compensation, owner-operator coverage, bonds and permits, safety services, accident packets

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight Marvin Johnson & Associates for its prompt, personal service and agents who know the trucking business.

9. Marquee Insurance Group, for Load Board-Connected Small Carriers

Marquee Insurance Group was founded in Roswell, Georgia, in 2014 by an ownership team with roots in freight brokerage and factoring, including Nolan Transportation Group and OTR Solutions. The trucking-only agency shops coverage across more than 30 A-rated markets, serves as DAT’s endorsed liability insurance partner, and supports carriers with its Express Lane portal and BOOST safety monitoring program. It takes an education-first approach with public trucking insurance guides and was named one of 10 founding members of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network in 2026.

Its Better Business Bureau reviews average 2.1, with some carriers citing slow responses on service requests. Founded in 2014, it is one of the younger agencies on this list, and its high-volume national model offers limited alternative risk options for fleets that want to move beyond guaranteed-cost policies.

Location: Roswell, GA

Founded: 2014

Avg. Review Score: 2.1/5.0

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, non-trucking liability, occupational accident, workers’ compensation, new authority programs, safety monitoring

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients frequently highlight Marquee Insurance Group for its wide carrier access and quick quotes for new and growing carriers.

10. Aronson Group, for Tech-Forward Fleets Under Ten Trucks

Aronson Group was founded in Bettendorf, Iowa, in 2017 and built its business around small fleets running one to nine trucks. Its technology-driven quoting process removes much of the paperwork from shopping coverage, and it offers new venture programs for first-year authorities and flexible policies for fleets whose size changes through the year. Its clients give it a 4.9 rating across Google reviews, with founder Thomas Aronson personally involved in the business.

As the youngest agency on this list, it has a shorter track record through hard insurance markets. It works with a narrower set of carriers than larger agencies, offers few contractor-specific programs for fleets that lease on owner-operators, and has no captive or self-insurance option for fleets that grow past ten units.

Location: Bettendorf, IA

Founded: 2017

Avg. Review Score: 4.9/5.0

Price Range: $$$$

Services: Commercial auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, new venture programs, flexible policies for changing fleets, FMCSA filings, certificates

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients consistently praise Aronson Group for a seamless online experience, knowledgeable agents and quick turnaround.

11. Kapnick Insurance, for Michigan Towing and Transportation Operators

Kapnick Insurance was founded in Adrian, Michigan, in 1946 and remains a family-owned, privately held firm with offices in Adrian, Ann Arbor, Troy and Grand Rapids. Its transportation and towing practice pairs risk management advisory with client executives who know the towing community, and the firm has added specialists to extend its transportation service into Minnesota and Wisconsin. Insurance Journal named Kapnick its Best Agency to Work For, and it has been recognized among Crain’s Cool Places to Work in Michigan.

Employee benefits make up a large share of its business, so trucking is one specialty among many. Its transportation practice leans toward towing, which leaves over-the-road small fleets and leased owner-operators with fewer specialized programs, and its public client reviews average 3.0 across listings.

Location: Adrian, MI (additional offices in Ann Arbor, Troy and Grand Rapids)

Founded: 1946

Avg. Review Score: 3.0/5.0

Price Range: $$$

Services: Commercial auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, towing operations coverage, workers’ compensation, risk management advisory, employee benefits

Summary of Online Reviews
Clients consistently praise Kapnick Insurance for its knowledgeable towing specialists and responsive client executives.

The Best Small Fleet Insurance Agencies by Specialty

We also broke down the top small fleet insurance agencies into three subcategories based on common buyer priorities.

The Best for Budgeting Your First Full-Fleet Renewal

  1. Truck Writers
  2. Marquee Insurance Group
  3. Reliance Partners
  4. OOIDA Truck Insurance
  5. Aronson Group

The Best for Moving Beyond Guaranteed-Cost Coverage

  1. Truck Writers
  2. Cottingham & Butler
  3. TrueNorth Companies
  4. Joe Morten & Son
  5. OOIDA Truck Insurance

The Best for Fleets Built on Leased Owner-Operators

  1. TrueNorth Companies
  2. Truck Writers
  3. OOIDA Truck Insurance
  4. RJS Truck Insurance
  5. Reliance Partners

Ready to build an insurance program around how your small fleet actually runs? Request a quote from Truck Writers and get matched with a dedicated account team today.

Sources

  1. Your Trucking Insurance Experts Since 1983.
  2. Truck Writers Celebrates 3 Generations of Family-Focused Success.
  3. Highway Launches Highway Certified Insurance Agencies: A New Standard for Trust in Brokered Freight.
  4. Reduce Turnover and Improve Independent Contractor Health with TrueChoices.
  5. Cottingham & Butler Transportation Group.
  6. Joe Morten & Son, Inc..
  7. Occupational Accident.
  8. OOIDA Truck Insurance and Small Trucking Businesses.
  9. Trucking Insurance From the Freight Specialists.
  10. Reliance Partners Reviews.
  11. RJS Truck Insurance.
  12. Marquee Insurance Group Customer Reviews.
  13. Marvin Johnson & Associates.
  14. Official Company Information.
  15. Marquee Insurance Group, DAT’s Liability Insurance Partner.
  16. Aronson Group.

Blaine, MN

8970 West 35W Service Dr. NE
Suite 200
Blaine, MN 55449

Welcome, MN

605 North Guide Street
Welcome, MN 56181

Also, providing service in Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, North Dakota, South Dakota and nationwide.