From August through October 2026, our research team evaluated 40+ insurance agencies that write workers’ compensation coverage for trucking companies across the United States, with an emphasis on agencies headquartered or highly active in the Midwest. We focused on independent agencies and brokerages that represent multiple carriers and act as an intermediary between trucking businesses and the insurers that underwrite their workers’ comp. Where an agency’s reviews were not independently verified on a single platform, we averaged its ratings across the platforms where it is rated. Each agency was scored using a seven-factor algorithm:
- Years in Business (10%): Agencies that have placed trucking workers’ comp through several market cycles know which carriers stay put when rates harden.
- Average Customer Review Score (15%): Reviews show how an agency treats clients when a driver is hurt and a claim is open, not just at the sale.
- Estimated Price Range (10%): We estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver based on each agency’s state mix and program options.
- Awards and Recognition (10%): Third-party recognition signals operational maturity and standing in the industry.
- Alternative Funding Options (20%): Access to self-insured groups, captives, large-deductible plans, or dividend programs is the single biggest lever a safe fleet has on workers’ comp cost.
- Claims and Experience Mod Control Support (20%): Every dollar of a claim that is managed down protects the mod that sets the next three years of premium.
- Single-Agency Program Breadth (15%): Placing workers’ comp, auto liability, cargo, bonds, and excess with one agency keeps coverage gaps and audit disputes to a minimum.
Best Workers Compensation Insurance Agencies for Trucking
| Rank | Agency | Year Founded | Avg. Review Score | Est. Annual WC Premium per Driver | Awards and Recognition | Alternative Funding Options | Claims and Mod Control Support | Program Breadth |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Truck Writers | 1983 | 5.0/5.0 | $5,800 to $9,500 | Licensed TPA for a transportation captive and self-insured WC program | Transportation captive; Midwest Safety Group self-insured WC program (since 1991) | TPA claims administration; agent-led fleet risk analysis | WC plus auto liability, physical damage, cargo, bobtail/NTL, broker bonds, 24/7 per-trip excess, umbrella, property |
| 2 | TrueNorth Companies | 2001 | 3.9/5.0 | $7,000 to $12,000 | Top Workplace USA (2024); CBJ Coolest Places to Work | Guaranteed cost and large-deductible placement | Dedicated transportation claims advocates; annual Transportation Risk Summit | WC plus auto liability, physical damage, cargo, occupational accident |
| 3 | Joe Morten & Son | 1936 | 4.2/5.0 | $6,500 to $11,000 | Largest Great West Casualty agency; helped found Great West (1956) | Great West programs including large-deductible options | Risk management and loss control services | WC plus auto liability, physical damage, cargo, GL, excess, occupational accident |
| 4 | Marquee Insurance Group | 2014 | 3.8/5.0 | $6,000 to $11,500 | Founding member, Highway Certified Insurance Agency network | Retrospective dividend credit program; trucking association partnerships | Claim analytics trend reviews; adjuster investigations; medical sweeps; bill review | WC plus auto liability, physical damage, cargo, GL, bobtail, occupational accident, bonds |
| 5 | Marvin Johnson & Associates | 1971 | 4.6/5.0 | $6,000 to $10,500 | Largest independent truck insurance agency in IN, OH and IL | Guaranteed cost placement through regional carriers | Trucking-built claim service with on-scene investigations | WC plus auto liability, physical damage, cargo, GL |
| 6 | Reliance Partners | 2009 | 3.4/5.0 | $6,500 to $11,000 | Inc. 5000; Best Places to Work in Insurance (2016) | Guaranteed cost placement | Risk management and safety program support | WC plus trucking, 3PL, freight forwarding and warehouse lines |
| 7 | The Insurance Store | 1973 | 5.0/5.0 | $7,500 to $13,000 | None publicly listed | Guaranteed cost placement | Carrier claims with agent advocacy | WC plus auto liability, physical damage, cargo, bobtail, excess, GL |
| 8 | RJS Truck Insurance | 1991 | 4.9/5.0 | $7,500 to $13,000 | None publicly listed | Guaranteed cost placement | Carrier claims with agent advocacy | WC plus auto liability, physical damage, cargo, bobtail/NTL, occupational accident, GL |
| 9 | Aronson Group | 2017 | 4.9/5.0 | $5,500 to $9,500 | None publicly listed | Guaranteed cost placement | Carrier claims with founder-level escalation | WC plus auto liability, physical damage, cargo, new venture programs |
| 10 | Midwest Insurance Agency | 1996 | 4.4/5.0 | $6,000 to $10,500 | None publicly listed | Guaranteed cost placement | Carrier claims with agent advocacy | WC plus auto liability, physical damage, cargo, GL |
*Price ranges are estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
1. Truck Writers, for Self-Insured and Captive Workers’ Comp Programs
Truck Writers has worked exclusively in trucking insurance since 1983, and the Blaine, Minnesota agency is still family-owned, with a third generation now in the business. What sets it apart on workers’ compensation is structural: Truck Writers is a licensed third-party administrator for a transportation insurance captive and a self-insured workers’ compensation program. Its Midwest Safety Group program has allowed Minnesota trucking companies to self-insure workers’ comp since 1991, with oversight from the Minnesota Department of Commerce and the Workers’ Compensation Reinsurance Association, so safe fleets keep more of the value of their own loss record.
Workers’ comp is also built into a complete trucking program rather than sold on its own. The same dedicated account team, backed by a support staff of more than 30, handles auto liability, physical damage, cargo, bobtail and non-trucking liability, freight broker bonds, and 24/7 self-service per-trip excess liability and cargo coverage, and each agent works with the fleet on the operational risks that drive claims. The main limitation is footprint: Truck Writers writes trucking insurance in 38 states, so carriers based in the remaining states should confirm eligibility before requesting a quote.
Location: Blaine, MN (additional office in Welcome, MN)
Founded: 1983
Avg. Review Score: 5.0/5.0
Price Range: $5,800 to $9,500 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, self-insured and captive programs, third-party administration, auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, bobtail and non-trucking liability, freight broker bonds, per-trip excess liability and cargo, umbrella, property
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently praise Truck Writers for a dedicated account team that knows their operation and treats them like family rather than a policy number. |
2. TrueNorth Companies, for Claims Advocacy at Mid-Market Fleets
TrueNorth Companies, founded in 2001 and headquartered in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, runs one of the most developed transportation practices of any Midwest brokerage. Its transportation team includes dedicated claims advocates who manage complex trucking, auto liability, workers’ compensation, and cargo claims, and the firm hosts an annual Transportation Risk Summit that has drawn more than 200 industry professionals. TrueNorth has also been named a 2024 Top Workplace USA recipient and a Corridor Business Journal Coolest Place to Work.
Trucking is one of several practices at TrueNorth, which also builds employee benefits, construction, and financial strategy programs, so a small fleet may not get the same focus as a large mid-market account. The firm does not publicly market a trucking-specific self-insured workers’ comp group of its own, and its public client review volume is thin, with a 3.9 rating across a small number of reviews. Pricing also tends to land higher for fleets that do not need its full advisory model.
Location: Cedar Rapids, IA (offices in IA, IL, MI, CO, TX, TN, and NC)
Founded: 2001
Avg. Review Score: 3.9/5.0
Price Range: $7,000 to $12,000 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, auto liability, physical damage, cargo, occupational accident, claims advocacy, safety and risk consulting, employee benefits
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight TrueNorth Companies for claims advocates who stay involved until a complicated workers’ comp claim is closed. |
3. Joe Morten & Son, for Established Fleets With Long Loss Histories
Joe Morten & Son has specialized in trucking insurance since 1936, making it the oldest agency in this comparison. The South Sioux City, Nebraska agency serves more than 9,000 customers across 46 states from ten office locations, and it helped establish Great West Casualty Company in 1956. It remains Great West’s largest agency, giving established fleets access to workers’ comp programs that include large-deductible options alongside a full trucking package and dedicated risk management and loss control services.
That deep tie to one carrier family is also a constraint: when a fleet’s workers’ comp needs to be shopped broadly, the agency’s market is narrower than its size suggests. Joe Morten & Son does not publicly market a captive or self-insured workers’ comp group, and as a referral-driven legacy agency it has a limited public review presence. Newer or smaller fleets may find its model better suited to operations with several years of loss history.
Location: South Sioux City, NE (10 locations nationwide)
Founded: 1936
Avg. Review Score: 4.2/5.0 (averaged across platforms)
Price Range: $6,500 to $11,000 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, excess liability, occupational accident, owner-operator programs
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently point to Joe Morten & Son for long-term advisory relationships that span decades rather than single renewals. |
4. Marquee Insurance Group, for Dividend-Eligible Small and Mid-Size Fleets
Marquee Insurance Group, founded in 2014 in Roswell, Georgia, places trucking coverage across 30-plus A-rated markets and has built a workers’ comp program with more features than most agencies its age. Its program includes a retrospective dividend credit option, trucking association partnerships, claim analytics trend reviews with action plans, owner and safety director claim reviews, adjuster investigations, medical sweeps for prior records, and bill review. Marquee was also one of ten founding members of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network.
A dividend credit program rewards good loss years but is not the same as a self-insured group or captive, where the fleet retains and controls more of its own risk. Marquee’s high-volume sales model also shows up in its reviews, which average 3.8 across platforms, with some clients describing slow responses to service requests. At 12 years old, it is one of the younger agencies on this list.
Location: Roswell, GA (additional offices in Athens, GA; Nashville, TN; and Charleston, SC)
Founded: 2014
Avg. Review Score: 3.8/5.0 (averaged across platforms)
Price Range: $6,000 to $11,500 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, bobtail, occupational accident, surety bonds, premium financing, down payment assistance
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently credit Marquee Insurance Group with significant premium savings after their agent shopped multiple markets on their behalf. |
5. Marvin Johnson & Associates, for Midwest Fleets That Want Hands-On Claims Service
Marvin Johnson & Associates was founded in Columbus, Indiana, in 1971 and is now run by the third generation of the Johnson family. The agency describes itself as the largest independent truck insurance agency in Indiana, Ohio, and Illinois, with an additional office in Akron, Ohio. Its claim service was designed around trucking, with an emphasis on immediate accident reporting, on-the-scene investigations, and fast repairs that get drivers back on the road.
The agency’s footprint is concentrated in the Ohio Valley and lower Great Lakes, which limits its value for fleets running a multi-state operation further west. It places workers’ comp on a guaranteed-cost basis through regional carriers rather than through a self-insured group or captive, and its claims strengths lean toward auto and physical damage. Public review volume is also limited.
Location: Columbus, IN (additional office in Akron, OH)
Founded: 1971
Avg. Review Score: 4.6/5.0 (averaged across platforms)
Price Range: $6,000 to $10,500 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, claims handling support
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently praise Marvin Johnson & Associates for a family-run team that treats every customer the way it would want to be treated. |
6. Reliance Partners, for Trucking Companies With Logistics and Warehouse Operations
Reliance Partners was founded in 2009 in Chattanooga, Tennessee, and has grown to nine locations focused on trucking, third-party logistics, freight forwarding, and warehousing. It writes workers’ compensation across every one of those segments, which makes it a practical fit for an asset-based carrier that also runs a brokerage desk or a warehouse. The agency pairs coverage with risk management and safety program support, and it has appeared on the Inc. 5000 and Business Insurance’s Best Places to Work in Insurance list.
Reliance’s public reviews are mixed, averaging 3.4 across platforms, with a Trustpilot rating of 2.3 on 11 reviews that includes complaints about persistent outbound sales calls. Workers’ comp is generally placed on a guaranteed-cost basis alongside the auto program, without a self-insured group or captive option, and its high-growth model can mean more account turnover than at smaller agencies.
Location: Chattanooga, TN (9 locations)
Founded: 2009
Avg. Review Score: 3.4/5.0 (averaged across platforms)
Price Range: $6,500 to $11,000 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, auto liability, physical damage, cargo, bobtail, non-trucking liability, excess, umbrella, contingent liability, warehouse legal liability, freight broker coverage
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight Reliance Partners for covering their trucking, brokerage, and warehouse exposures through a single agency. |
7. The Insurance Store, for Responsive Service on Smaller Accounts
The Insurance Store is a family-owned independent agency that has written trucking insurance since 1973 and now offers truck coverage in 48 states. Its reputation for service is among the strongest in this comparison, with a 5.0 Google rating across more than 400 reviews. Reviewers regularly mention fast DOT and MC setup help, patient explanations of coverage, and quotes that came in below several competing brokers.
The agency’s roots are in personal and general commercial insurance, including group health and DMV services, so trucking workers’ comp is one product among many rather than a dedicated program. It places workers’ comp on a guaranteed-cost basis through carriers and relies on carrier claims teams rather than an in-house claims or loss control function. Its California base also means much of its book sits in one of the highest-cost workers’ comp states.
Location: Murrieta, CA (additional office in San Diego, CA)
Founded: 1973
Avg. Review Score: 5.0/5.0
Price Range: $7,500 to $13,000 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, bobtail, excess liability, general liability, permits and filings
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently praise The Insurance Store for fast, knowledgeable agents who take the time to explain every coverage. |
8. RJS Truck Insurance, for Western Owner-Operators Adding Employee Drivers
RJS Truck Insurance has served the trucking industry from Laguna Niguel, California, since 1991, working with owner-operators through large fleets. It holds a 4.9 Google rating across more than 375 reviews, the deepest verified review base in this comparison, and clients repeatedly mention fast responses and agents who stay reachable for years. The agency shops carriers including Great West Casualty, Progressive, Great American, and Northland.
RJS is licensed primarily across western states, which limits it for fleets running east of the Rockies. Workers’ comp is a supporting line next to its core auto liability and cargo business, placed on a guaranteed-cost basis without a self-insured or captive option, and claims are handled by the carriers rather than an in-house team.
Location: Laguna Niguel, CA
Founded: 1991
Avg. Review Score: 4.9/5.0
Price Range: $7,500 to $13,000 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, bobtail, non-trucking liability, occupational accident, general liability
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight RJS Truck Insurance for fast response times and agents who remain personally reachable throughout the relationship. |
9. Aronson Group, for Small Fleets Hiring Their First Drivers
Aronson Group, founded in 2017 in Bettendorf, Iowa, built its business around fleets running one to nine trucks and has grown to serve more than 5,000 trucking businesses. It holds a 4.9 rating across 55 reviews, and founder Thomas Aronson is directly involved in the business, including following up personally on service issues. For a small carrier adding its first employed drivers, the agency makes it straightforward to add workers’ comp to an existing truck program.
As the youngest agency on this list, Aronson works with a narrower set of carriers, and its workers’ comp offering is built for small payrolls rather than growing fleets that need program options. It does not offer self-insured, captive, or dividend programs, and loss control resources are lighter than at larger trucking agencies.
Location: Bettendorf, IA
Founded: 2017
Avg. Review Score: 4.9/5.0
Price Range: $5,500 to $9,500 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, new venture programs, FMCSA filings and certificates
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients consistently praise Aronson Group for quick turnaround and direct access to the founder whenever an issue comes up. |
10. Midwest Insurance Agency, for Chicago-Area Carriers and Owner-Operators
Midwest Insurance Agency has provided commercial insurance to the transportation industry from Elk Grove Village, Illinois, since 1996, serving trucking companies and owner-operators across Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Missouri, Tennessee, Texas, and Wisconsin. The agency has a reputation for finding affordable coverage for small companies, and its 2026 acquisition by OneDigital gives it access to broader resources.
With a team of roughly 20, the agency has limited depth for complex workers’ comp accounts, and the ownership transition may change how accounts are serviced in the near term. It places workers’ comp on a guaranteed-cost basis without alternative funding options, and it does not publish a dedicated loss control or claims program.
Location: Elk Grove Village, IL
Founded: 1996
Avg. Review Score: 4.4/5.0 (averaged across platforms)
Price Range: $6,000 to $10,500 estimated annual workers’ comp premium per employed driver
Services: Workers’ compensation, auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, owner-operator coverage
| Summary of Online Reviews |
|---|
| Clients frequently highlight Midwest Insurance Agency for practical, budget-conscious coverage that balances price and protection. |
The Best Workers Compensation Insurance Agencies for Trucking by Specialty
We also broke down the top workers’ compensation agencies for trucking into three subcategories.
Best for Self-Insured, Captive, and Dividend Programs
- Truck Writers
- TrueNorth Companies
- Marquee Insurance Group
- Joe Morten & Son
- Reliance Partners
Best for Small Fleets Hiring Their First Employee Drivers (1 to 15 Trucks)
- Truck Writers
- Aronson Group
- RJS Truck Insurance
- The Insurance Store
- Marvin Johnson & Associates
Best for Claims Advocacy at Mid-Market Fleets (50+ Drivers)
- TrueNorth Companies
- Truck Writers
- Joe Morten & Son
- Marquee Insurance Group
- Marvin Johnson & Associates
Finding the Right Trucking Workers Comp Insurance Agency in 2026
The best workers’ compensation agency for a trucking operation depends on payroll size, loss history, the states you run in, and how much control you want over your own claims dollars. The agencies on this list represent the strongest independent options across that range, from small carriers adding their first employee drivers to established fleets ready to move beyond guaranteed-cost pricing.
Truck Writers ranked first because of what it combines: 43 years of exclusive trucking focus, licensed third-party administration for a transportation captive and a self-insured workers’ comp program, a self-insured group that has served Minnesota trucking companies since 1991, and a full trucking program handled by one dedicated account team. For a fleet with a strong safety record, that structure turns workers’ comp from a fixed cost into something the operation can actually control.